Last Saturday (May 22) visitors to the Hugh Lane Gallery (Parnell Square, Dublin) met with an unusual sight: a circle of 11 people, sitting silently. Ten poets and an artist. Well, if thevisitors had come in at certain times (every 50 minutes) they would have seen one of the people strike a gong and then see the circle disperse, and then return punctually ten minutes later. Punctually? Poets? Is that possible? Yes indeed. Chris Doris, the creator of this artwork, had his poets well in hand.
This ‘silent circle’ was the brainchild of Chris, an artist ‘who utilizes silence as a medium of shared public enquiry’ . Which means… Well, I was one of the poet-participants and I’m not sure I can explain exactly what was happening. For one thing, there was no ‘exactitude’ about it. I do know that it was a deeply affecting experience for me. Just alone on the level of being without TV, Radio, conversation, books, internet, surrounding chatter, mobile-phone, door-bell ringing– that is to say: without all the vicissitudes of ‘modern life’ — Being ‘away’ from everything for a few hours without any of these things was a unique experience. THAT was one important aspect of the silence Chris was constructing throughout the day, through which the participants one could see/experience something else about themselves, something not manufactured for them by their surrounding milieau.
But to utilize this silence ‘as a medium of shared public enquiry’? I’m not good at explaining this because, although the experience allowed me to see into myself without the usual hinderance of my ‘cultural clutter’, I don’t know what effect the artwork had on visitors to the museum. Once one allows the silence to do its work, one gradually sinks (or rises?) to a plane where the surrounds are almost shut out. So therefore I was sometimes only partially aware of people coming and going, and of people sitting down with us for a while in the ring of chairs placed outside the circle. One lady, directly in my line of vision, stayed a considerable time. I wonder how she felt? Was the circle working for her too? In what way? What enquiries was she making of her self? … How one asseses this idea of ‘shared public enquiry’ I’m not sure.
Another aspect of the experience that I began to feel as the day wore was that the silence in the circle became somewhat tangible, though ”tangible’ is the wrong word for something as elusive as this kind of shared event. However, something was generated by the circle which somehow locked us in together. This may have been just the effect of the ‘bonding’ any group will feel after being together for some time, but sometimes it had a different ‘quality’. This feeling was stronger for me in the later hours in the afternoon. How much of it was something, or how much of it was imagined, or the result of bonding I can’t say. However this sustained period of silence was very relaxing and brought to mind Wordsworth’s phrase in his great ‘Tintern Abbey’ poem about ‘seeing into the life of things’:
“… that serene and blessed mood,
in which the affections gently lead us on,-
Until, the breath of this coporeal frame
And even the motion of our human blood
almost suspended, we are laid asleep
In body and become a living soul:
While with an eye made quiet by the power
of harmony, and the deep power of joy,
We see into the life of things… ” (from ‘Lines Coposed a Few Miles above Tintern Abbey’‘, 1798)
I hope to talk to Chris Doris again about all this sometime. He’s bound to help me out, as he did with us all the day(Friday) before the artwork. He has 20 years of academic and practical research in Eastern philosophy, Western psychology and science. That may sound a bit forbidding if you haven’t met him, but in fact he is very amiable and wears his learning lightly .
The poets were Chris Agee, Paddy Bushe, Seamus Cashman, Patrick Chapman, Rachel Hegarty,Kevin Higgins, Eamonn Lynskey, Nuala Ni Dhomhnaill, Eileen Sheehan, and Barbara Smith.
Thanks also to Rachel, who sat with us ready to catch anyone who fell over from all the mental exertion and bring outside for revival. Fortunately this did not happen. Despite rumours to the contrary, poets are tough birds!
(Photo by Mark Condren of the Sunday Tribune)